Home page of CAMCE Current politics comment international military Sociology Finance enterprise Labour Union Safeguarding rights obtain employment forum Blog theory character Netview picture Sports automobile Culture Painting and Calligraphy education read entertainment Travel? green urban construction community Work part-time

 CAMCE Comments

character

In the Zhao Yu case, there is no justice without truth

Zhang Bingjian
2019-02-20 10:09:52 Source: Qianjiang Evening News

In the past two days, "acting bravely for a just cause" prevented female neighbors from being invaded into the house, and the incident of being detained for 14 days on suspicion of intentional injury caused widespread concern in the national public opinion. Many media and netizens have been defending Zhao Yu, a man who "acted bravely for a just cause", and directed their criticism at another party, the "perpetrator" Li, and the public security department who detained Zhao.

On the contrary, "acting bravely for a just cause" was detained and faced with huge compensation. Seeing such a scenario, people with a little sense of justice would jump and swear, which is simply black and white. Then, with the media's investigation of this matter, more and more details emerged. For example, as a "violent person", Mr. Li not only did not receive the relevant punishment, but also played mahjong while being interviewed by the media; For another example, Mr. Li called Zhao Yu's father in private and asked for privacy on the condition that his sentence could be commuted. Such a plot seems to be developing in the direction of netizens' imagination. Good people are wronged and bad guys are arrogant.

But in fact, at present, the media may not be so clear about the presentation of relevant parties. For example, the injured woman said that Li intended to rape, and then she resisted the call for help. But the question is, after Li reported the case, why did the woman not tell the truth to the police at that time? There is no reliable argument for this doubt. Especially now, the two parties have different opinions on many details, which on the contrary makes the matter even more clouded. If too much attention is paid to such details as "whether Mr. Li was invited upstairs by a woman" and "whether Zhao Yu knew the injured woman", the core issue of the incident will be ignored, that is, whether Mr. Li was actually committing violence when Zhao Yu "acted bravely".

Therefore, the purpose of this matter is to restore the scene. Some lawyers believed that whether Zhao Yu was in "self-defense" had nothing to do with whether "an unknown man attempted to rape". The key was whether the woman was subjected to violence at that time, which depended on the evidence. However, the current evidence is mainly the opinions of both sides at that time, as well as the investigation reports of some media. There is no more "solid" evidence like monitoring, let alone the reliable and authoritative characterization and conclusions of the authoritative departments.

From the present evidence, Zhao Yu's statement seems to be more credible. He not only restored many details of the scene, but also had strong circumstantial evidence from the injured woman and neighbors. In addition, the "decision not to approve the arrest" made by the Procuratorate is also a very favorable support for Zhao Yu to a certain extent. At present, the public security department has been involved in the investigation, and it is believed that the final truth will soon be known to the society.

In addition, in this matter, more attention should be paid to the social mentality reflected by the one-sided public opinion. I'm afraid there is also a simple justice view of the majority of netizens: good people should be rewarded, and bad people should be brought to justice. I'm afraid that people here are more likely to use "Zhao Yu's story" to pour out their dissatisfaction with the indifferent society. People hope that justice will be upheld and more heroes will appear. This simple desire should be paid attention to and encouraged. However, for a rational society, all value judgments, right and wrong judgments should be based on the truth. Before the truth is known, what we can do is probably to wait for the truth. Without truth, where can justice come from?

Therefore, it is urgent for the local public security department to verify and implement all the doubts and details as soon as possible. If Zhao Yu is truly a righteous man, he should be given justice and even some compensation, rather than hurting the hearts of the righteous and the simple sense of justice of netizens.

Edit: Zhang Weining

Cartoon Review

Mid hour rating

  • Middle time review: why does Mu'an Society blow the "wind of cooperation"

    Entering the second decade of the 21st century, the international order and global security are beginning to face new challenges. Terrorism and extremism frequently commit crimes, financial crisis and debt crisis follow one after another, and technological development and climate change bring uncertainty

  • Three Possibilities of Venezuela's Situation

    Since January 23, when Guaido, President of the Venezuelan Parliament, announced his assumption of the post of "Interim President", the situation in Venezuela has remained tense. At present, the President of Venezuela Maduro is still supported by the Supreme Court and the military, but the foreign intervention led by the United States is trying to continue to exert pressure on the Venezuela government from economic, diplomatic and even military aspects.

  • Mid hour review: How to deal with food waste?

    On January 8, the Ministry of Agriculture and Rural Affairs held a national long-distance training on the prevention and control of African swine fever. Yu Kangzhen, the vice minister of the Ministry, said that it was necessary to "eliminate the use of kitchen residues to feed pigs". Prior to this, the head of the Animal Husbandry and Veterinary Bureau of the Ministry said that one of the reasons for the occurrence of African swine fever in China was the use of kitchen residues in the feeding process.

  • Mid term Labor Review: When will the deadlock of building the wall in the United States be solved

    Since December 22 last year, the US government has been partially "suspended" for more than 20 days, setting the record of the longest government shutdown in US history. U.S. President Trump insisted on "no wall, no budget", while congressional Democrats were determined to fight the president to the end.

character

  • In the Zhao Yu case, there is no justice without truth

    In the past two days, "acting bravely for a just cause" prevented female neighbors from being invaded into the house, and the incident of being detained for 14 days on suspicion of intentional injury caused widespread concern in the national public opinion. Many media and netizens have been detained and faced with huge compensation for Zhao Yu, a man who fought against injustice and acted bravely for a just cause. Seeing such a plot, anyone with a sense of justice would jump and swear, which is a reversal of black and white.

  • What Merkel's "shock" shows

    The "232 Investigation" report on the tariff of imported automobiles from the United States will be announced soon. The US government has repeatedly threatened to impose tariffs of up to 25% on imported cars. At the recently concluded Munich security conference, Merkel said in a rare tone of dissatisfaction that if German cars were seen as a threat to the national security of the United States, "then we were really shocked".

  • From the short gathering platform to the distant dream

    Hao Kang is a railway driver who runs freight at Yulin Station in Shaanxi Province; Lei Jie is a train steward who commutes between Xi'an and Wuhai West. The same is the love story of Hao Kang and Lei Jie from Suide, Shaanxi, who met at 1:37. During the Spring Festival, after being broadcasted on CCTV News Network, they quickly brushed the screen, conveying love and stirring people's hearts in the public opinion.

  • Zhai Tianlin's Personnel Establishment Collapses and Eating Disgraces Academics

    Zhai Tianlin, the "academic bully" star who just played a fighting role in the Spring Festival Gala, has recently been subjected to a 360 degree academic crackdown. Actors who are used to showing off their "writing papers" on social media see things getting worse and worse, and the Beijing Film Academy and Peking University Guanghua School of Management can't sit still. The former said that the school attaches great importance to the construction of academic ethics

One week watch

Ranking

News Calendar
About us | Advertising services | contact us | Map of this station | Submission mailbox | Copyright Notice |Illegal and bad information report hotline: 010-84151598 | Online extortion and paid deletion report hotline: 010-84151598
Copyright © 2008-2018 by www.workercn.cn. all rights reserved
Scan code for attention

CAMCE WeChat


CAMCE Weibo


CAMCE Treble


Workers' Daily
client
×