With the coming of graduation season, many college students have passed the blind review of their papers, passed the defense, and are enjoying their last college years, and are full of expectations for their future work and life.
There are also quite a number of students who are busy with their thesis defense. If they fail to pass the defense, it may mean that they need to continue to revise the thesis that has been changed countless times, which means that they need to postpone their defense, and it may mean that they may fail to find a good job.
Generally speaking, failing to pass the oral defense is a problem of the academic itself. Either the thesis has serious problems or the respondent has poor performance. If so, it is understandable that the oral defense fails to pass the oral defense. However, some students said that they sometimes felt that it was not all about papers or defense.
A student in Jiangsu failed in his defense. The teacher asked him to correct a small problem, and he finished it five minutes after he returned home. Then he would participate in the second debate and pay 1000 yuan for the defense. Some students' papers needed major changes, but the defense was passed.
He thinks that his failure is related to the low level of his tutor. His tutor is very young, and none of the lecturers has been rated.
A student in a college in Liaoning also failed to pass the defense, and his tutor was also a new teacher. Interestingly, the teacher of the defense team asked the students to modify the topic of the paper, but the student's own tutor said that it was not necessary to modify the paper. The paper was no problem, and he directly participated in the second debate.
The students were immediately confused. They didn't know whether there was any problem with the paper or who to listen to. It was neither correct nor unchanged. They were in a dilemma.
The following student's surname is Lu, and his situation is even more special.
Lu's blind review scores of master's theses are all above 80 points. His thesis can be recognized by two teachers at the same time, which indicates that there should be no major problem.
He also published a SCI paper and a Chinese core paper, which is also quite good, indicating that he is also excellent. However, during the graduation defense, his thesis was directly overturned by the dean of the college, who said that his crowd was wrong and the data needed to be reorganized, that is, the thesis must be completely redone. He has only one week to revise his paper, and the time is quite tight. He really doesn't know where to start.
More seriously, Lu's off campus tutor, who is also the top ten hospital director in China, was disqualified on the spot.
The so-called "off campus tutors" are teachers who are hired from places outside the school to take the responsibility of guiding graduate students on campus. They mainly assist the on campus tutors to participate in the training of graduate students. They usually have rich professional knowledge and strong working ability in the industry.
Such a thing is really rare, so some people speculate that there may be academic conflicts between the tutors, and Lu was trapped. If this is true, it would be unimaginable. Students worked hard for several months and were denied within a day. However, everyone is just guessing, and there is no real evidence.
More strangely, all the teachers told Lu that it was not his problem. So, whose problem is it?
Lu Tong said that the dean of the college made it clear that he would not sign his name to confer a degree. If he fails to correct his thesis within a week, there is a great possibility of delay in completing it.
However, Lu didn't think about it so much. He felt that there were problems with his paper. He said that although he did publish a lot of relevant articles, if carefully considered, this "crowd" really needs to be modified, and it is not unreasonable for others to stick to this point. He can't manage so much now. He just wants to revise his thesis.
It is hoped that the academic community can be pure and create a good academic atmosphere for those who devote themselves to research. It is hoped that too much worldly wisdom and even intrigues will not be mixed, giving students more faith.
What do you think?
(The picture is from the network, intrusion and deletion, thank you.)
Special statement: The above content (including pictures or videos, if any) is uploaded and released by users of "Netease" on our media platform, and this platform only provides information storage services.
Notice: The content above (including the pictures and videos if any) is uploaded and posted by a user of NetEase Hao, which is a social media platform and only provides information storage services.
