Procuratorial Highlights
Ten typical cases of the year: irregular supervision of interrogation
Time: January 17, 2022 Author: News source: [Font size: large | in | Small
The third phase is launched by The case of Wang's robbery, interrogation and non-standard supervision handled by Ma'anshan People's Procuratorate

   Brief introduction: On December 4, 1995, the defendant Wang Moumou was arrested with the approval of the People's Procuratorate of Ma'anshan City for robbery, and then was ordered to be arrested at large. On May 28, 2020, the defendant Wang Moumou returned to surrender. The case was investigated and concluded by the public security organ. On July 23, 2020, the defendant Wang was suspected of robbery and was transferred to the People's Procuratorate of Maanshan for examination and prosecution.  

   After the case was accepted, the Ma'anshan Procuratorate carried out the work of reading the papers. According to the public security interrogation records, the defendant Wang confessed all the facts of the 33 crimes committed. After reading the papers, the Court informed Wang that Wang confessed only three times and the rest 30 times, which was significantly different from the interrogation records in the public security organ. In order to find out this fact, the Ma'anshan Municipal Procuratorate launched the investigation and verification procedure, obtained the synchronous audio and video recordings of the interrogation during the investigation stage, and carried out a comprehensive verification. It was found that the investigators directly made the false confession of the defendant Wang Moumou to admit all the robbery crimes, resulting in the false appearance of the defendant Wang Moumou's full confession.  

   After finding out that it is illegal for the public security organ to investigate and collect evidence, the Ma'anshan Procuratorate ruled out the interrogation record as illegal evidence according to law, and issued the Notice on Correcting Violations and the Notice on Explaining the Legality of Evidence Collection to the public security organ. The public security organ re interrogated the defendant Wang Moumou, objectively and truthfully produced the interrogation content, and issued the Situation Statement on September 21, 2020 to correct and reply to the illegal acts of investigation activities.  

   [Guide]  

   May 28, 2020  

   The defendant Wang is over  

   A fugitive career of nearly 25 years  

   Return to Ma'anshan to surrender  

   After the end of investigation by the investigation organ  

   Transfer to the procuratorial organ for examination and prosecution  

   Undertaking Procurator of Ma'anshan Municipal Procuratorate  

   Immediately carried out the work of reading and prompting  

   In the process of interrogation, Wang  

   Confessing only three of the crimes  

   The rest 30 cases were denied  

   And always emphasize that they should go to the investigation organ  

   He confessed three times when he surrendered  

   There is no change or repetition in the confession  

   This attracted the attention of the undertaker  

   Since this case is a major criminal case  

   Whether Wang XX truthfully confesses  

   Whether the plot of voluntary surrender can be determined directly  

   To find out whether the defendant Wang has changed before and after his statement  

   Ma'anshan Procuratorate has launched  

   Procedures for investigation of illegal acts  

   Retrieve synchronous audio and video recordings of interrogation during investigation  

   It took two days to record the eight hour interrogation  

   Fully checked with the interrogation record  

   When investigators are found interrogating  

   The record is not truthfully recorded according to Wang's confession  

   Part of the content Wang did not make a statement at all  

   Has created the illusion that he confessed to all 33 crimes  

   Cause major contradiction between the record and the confession  

   After finding out that the public security organ has violated the law in investigation and evidence collection  

   The court legally took the record of the interrogation  

   Exclusion as illegal evidence  

   And issue the Notice of Correcting Violations to the public security organ  

   And Notice on Explaining the Legitimacy of Evidence Collection  

   Public security organs attach great importance to  

   The defendant Wang was interrogated again  

   Make the interrogation content objectively and truthfully  

   And issue the Situation Statement on September 21, 2020  

   Correct and reply to the illegal acts of investigation activities  

   The case was prosecuted on November 19, 2020  

   Ma'anshan Intermediate People's Court  

   First instance judgment will be issued on February 7, 2021  

   Defendant Wang Moumou commits robbery  

   Sentenced to life imprisonment, deprived of political rights for life  

   The second instance ruled to uphold the original judgment