Norwegian Whaling

minke whale-photo by Len 2040

Norway has hunted whales in its own waters for centuries,but key technological advances,such as the exploding harpoon cannon,developed by its whalers in the 19第三century,enabled the expansion of Norwegian whaling—and that of other nations—to an industrial scale over a much broader area.After World War I,in response to dwindling whale stocks and a shortfall of whale oil forits own market,some of Norway’s whalers returned to Norway’s own waters, establishing the foundation of modern Norwegian whaling in the North Atlantic.By the mid-1930 s,Norway dominated the global whaling industry,taking more than half of all whales killed and producing a large share of the world’s whale oil。

By the time the国际Whaling Commission(IWC)imposed aglobal moratorium on commercial whaling in1982,Norway was exporting to Japan most of the whale products from the approximately2000 minke whales it took in the North Atlantic each year.Norway formally objected to the IWC’s moratorium decision,which means that it is not bound by it.It also“took a reservation”to the ban on international trade in whale products imposed by the Convention on on International Trade in Endangered Species of Wild Fauna and Flora(CITES),which means it can trade legally with other CITES parties that hold reservations(Iceland and Japan)and with nonparties to the treaty。

1986,Norway initially undertook a small-scale scientific huntof minke whales。1993,however,it announced that it would resumecommercial whalingunder its objection。It has continued to whale for commercial purposes since that time,killing many hundreds of minke whales every year,almost exclusively for its domestic market.Since 1993,Norway has killed more than 14000 minke whales.Norway’s quotas have not been approved by the IWC,and are set using hometsbelow)that has not been agreed to by the IWC。(The IWC approved the most precautionary of the quota-setting options presented to it by the Scientific Committee.)

Consumption of whale meat is on the decline in Norway.A2019survey不可重复的不可重复设备:

  • Overall,only4percent of Norwegians polled admitted to eating whale meat“often,”while two-thirds either have never eaten it or only did so“along time ago.”
  • Younger people are even less interested in eating whales.None of those polled in the 18-29age group said they ate whale meat“often,”and21percent said they ate it only“rarely.”The vast majority—75percent—said they have never eaten it or only did so a long time ago。
  • Consumption is highest among those aged70andolder,with42percent eating whale meat least occasionally.Only9percent said they consumed whale meat often,however。

As sales have declined,the number of whaling boats participating in the Norwegian hunt has fallen,as more and more boats have preferred to focus on fishing.In2003,35whaling boats were registered in Norway;in2021,only17vessels were issued a license to hunt whales。

In2020,Norwegian whalers killed503 whales—less than half of the self-allocated annual quota,but still the highest total since2016.Three whaling vessels(theKato,theReinebuenand the,并且Fiskebank1)were responsible for63 percent of the whales killed in 2020。

There has also been a downturn in the number of large processing companies registered to buy and sell whale meat.The domestic market is so diminished,Norwegian whalers are removing only the most valuable cuts of meat from carcarcasses and discarding the rest at sea.The averageyield of meat per whale killed haled hayes, from a high of 1.5 metric tons per whale in 2000 to 1.29 metric tons in 2020.A growing number of whaling vessels have requested permission to sell whale meat directly to consumers,in an effort to cut out intermediaries and improve their profits。

The government continues to set high quotas and fund promotional campaigns and research into alternative uses of whale products,including for animal feed.It has introduced several marketing plans to encourage domestic whale meat consumption,including marketing whale burgers and tacos,mornizeng packaging for,for,including“ready to heat and serve”meals,and expanding the distribution system to ensure that the“new”products are available both in local markets and in national supermarket chains。In2017,the Norwegian government introduced a subsidized program to introduce schoolchildren to whale meat and to support marketing of minke whale meat。It has also looked to uses beyond human food for whale products,including the development of food supplements and animal feed.In recent years,the whaling industry has sold products tofur farms在地下管线下的路基边坡上施工near future

Norwegian whaling companies are also looking for export markets.One has even established a branch in Japan,to which it has exported more than600metric tons of frozen whale meat and blubber since2018.Norwegian whalers are also shipping whale meat toIceland-a whaling nation that has not hunted any whales since2019-and to the Faroe Islands。The government is now looking at markets for fresh whale meat,which sells at higher prices than frozen.AWI has called on airlines that serve Norway and Japan to pledge not to carry whale meat as airfreight。

Despite declining local demand,tourists to Norway are consuming whale meat in restaurants,based upon a mistaken belief that this represents a“typical”or“traditional”local product。Tourists are also purchasing nutritional supplements and skin creams containing whale oil。Because of the CITES trade ban,those who bring such products home to the European Union,the United States,and many other countries are breaking the law and could face significant penalties。

The impact of Norway’s hunt is not limited to the number of whales killed:On average,68 percent of whales taken in Norway’s hunt are female,and42.5 percent of those are pregnant.Norway’s whalso has serious repercussions for animal welfare.A出口,出口submitted in 2016to the North Atlantic Marine Mammal Commission and subsequently shared with the IWC by Norwegian authorities revealed that18percent of the whales shot by grenade-tipped harpoons did not die instantly。Within this group,the median time to death was6minutes.One whale took20-25minutes to die。

应力变形为Norway’s hunt,see the AWI-coauthored report从时间:How Modern Norway Clings to Its Whaling Past


YTHS AND FACTS on NORWEGIAN WHALING

 

YTH:

Whales eat large quantities of fish that are also food for other species,including humans.Thus,it makes sense to cull whale populations to ensure balance in the marine ecosystems。
 

FACT:

Countries in favor of resuming commercial whaling have argued that killing whales may increase fisheries’catches.At the IWC,this“whales eat fish”debate has been going on for years,with pro-whaling countries arguing that whaling should be resumed in order to protect fisheries catches。

In reality,the culprit behind the decline in fish populations is overfishing.In2020,theFood and Agriculture Organizationfound that34.2percent of fish stocks today are classified as overexploited and 59.6 percent are fully fished。In addition,a shocking35percent of the global fisheries harvest is either lost or wasted every year。

Research has shown that there is little overlap between what whales consume and the main species of fish targeted commercially.Many of the fish species that whales consume are not currently eaten by humans.Furthermore,although whales eat organisms that are high on the marine food chain,several large,fidash。,tuna and billfish)are far more important consumers of commercially targeted fish species compared to whales and other marine mammals.In addition,most populations of large whales targeted by commercial whalers have still not recovered to their pre-exploitation levels。

Due to the complexity of marine ecosystems,it has proven very difficult to determine just what impact the removal of atoppredator from the food chain has on commercially sought fish species.In some cases,however,removing atoppredator has led to an increase in the number of mid-level redatory cuspecies地下通风管.Further,recent scientificstudieshave found that whale species are an essential component of healthy,productive marine ecosystems,and could even help fish stocks rebound。

YTH:

None of the species caught are endangered.On the contrary,minke whales are stable,viable,and sustainable。
 

FACT:

In1985,the IWC declared that the minke whale stock targeted by Norwegian whalers was a“Protection Stock”due to decades of exploitation at high levels that had seriously depleted the stock。Following its implementation of a moratorium on commercial whaling in 1986,the IWC asked its Scientific Committee to developa precautionary approach on the setting of commercial whaling quotas in the event that the moratorium is lifted.In response,the committee developed the Revised Management Procedure(RMP)。One element of the RMP used to calculate quotas is the“tuning level”—the fraction of the pre-exploited whale population that would be left after100 years of operating the RMP。(For example,if the tuning level were set at0.90,that would mean that90 percent of the number of whales in a population or stock prior to active exploitation would remain after100 years of killing,if permitted.)The higher tuning levelused,the smaller the allowed quota。

The Scientific Committee offered a range of possible tuning levels to the IWC,from the least conservative(0.60)to the far more precautionary(0.72)。The IWC adopted the 0.72 tuning level in 1991and approved the RMP in 1994.In June of 2010, the Scientific Committee again stated that only the 0.72 tuning is the IWC’s agreed value.The0.72 level means that the number of catches would be set so as to allow at least72 percent of awhale population's initial abundance to be maintained.Though the IWC has accepted the RMP,the RMP, because the commercial whaling moratorium is still in place and the IWC has provided no advice on catch limits。

Norway initially set its quotas based on the 0.72 tuning level,but in 2001,the country switched to a0.66 level,as quotas would have been markedly reduced due to the higher-than-average proportion of female minke whales that were being killed.In2003,the government lowered the levelto2and dropped the level again,0.60,to,in2005.This was due in part to a Norwegian government policy change calling for more whales to be killed in order to benefit fisheries(see below)。This0.60 level continues to be used despite concerns repeatedly raised by the IWC。

Notably,recentstudiesby Norwegian scientists based on surveys indicate that the abundance of minke whales in the waters off Svalbard,akey location for Norwegian whalers,shows a considerable decrease(45%)compared to a2008survey,with the lowest number of whales seen since1995.Further,the most recent estimate from the Norwegian Sea also indicates a decrease in abundance,with the current estimate being the lowest over two survey cycles.In addition to these lower numbers,studies have found that there has been a分度,分度,分度,分度of North Atlantic minke whales over the course of the past two decades。

YTH:

The catch is ethically sound.According to the latest evaluation of Norwegian whaling from2015,Norwegian catchers are killing very effectively,with more than80percent of strikes causing immediate death or unconsciousness。
 

FACT:

Given that whales are only visible for a short period when they surface to breathe,the thorax(the initial target in the Norwegian hunt)and the brain(the target for a secondary rifle shot when the initial harpoon fails to kill a whale)offer only small,briefly accessible targets for a gunner standing on a moving platform on a shifting sea,often under difficult weather and sea conditions.For the 18 percent of whales that do not die or fall unconscious instantaneously,suffering can be prolonged。The most recent full data set from Norway(from the 2011 and 2012 seasons)shows that the median time to death for whales not registered instantly dead was6 minutes。One whale that had only been wounded was re-shot and died after20-25minutes。

Changes to whaling regulations threaten animal welfare.Between1993and2003,all Norwegian whaling vessels were required to carry an inspector on board.In2004,however,the government cut that coverage to only50 percent of vessels,and then completely did away with this requirement in 2006。Inspectors were replaced byan onboard“blue box”that records vessel position,engine speed,direction,harpoon shots,and the weight of the whale brought on deck.But it is not areal-time reporting device that can record the time to death for every whale shot.Experts have indicated that this device merely“may”give an indication as to whether the whale died quickly slowly。In2020,the government proposed to amend the whaling regulations,including to allow people with only one recent year of whaling experience to hunt whales.Lack of hunter experience,in addition to the absence of inspectors,could significantly increase suffering for hunted whales and threaten the safety of the crew。

Furthermore,the harpooner training program does not adequately reflect real life conditions,and training courses are not held annually。

YTH:

The catch is profitable.Norway has a viable whaling industry,despite zero subsidies and only one market outside Norway。
 

FACT:

Demand for whale meat appears to be declining in Norway,and the number of companies processing whale meat is far lower than in previous decades.In2020,Norwegian whalers killed503 whales—less than half of the self-allocated annual quota。To boost demand, the Norwegian government funds research into new uses for whale products and marketing campaigns for meat and blubber.Much of the whale is not even used;whalers are only removing the most valuable cuts of meat from carcarcasses and disposing of the rest at sea。

Source of myths